Skip to content

Guide

Review member appeals

Moderation & safety · 5 min read

When you ban a member, warn them, or suspend them for more than 7 days, they can appeal: ask your team to reconsider. Appeals wait in Admin → Moderation → Appeals, where you approve an appeal to lift the restriction or reject it. This article explains what's in the appeals queue, how to decide, and what the member sees.

Who can do this: Owners, admins, and moderators. A custom role needs Resolve moderation items to approve or reject; with only View moderation queue, it can read appeals. · Where: Web, in the admin console. · Plan: No plan requirement.

Which moderation decisions members can appeal

Decision Can the member appeal it?
Ban (community-wide) Yes. A banned member is taken to an appeal page when they try to sign in.
Suspension longer than 7 days, or with no end date Yes, from the appeal page they see when they try to sign in.
Suspension of 7 days or less No. It ends on its own.
Warning Yes, from the Appeal button on the warning notification.
Content removal No.
Ban Member or Mute Member in one space No. These don't stop the member signing in, so no appeal is created.

Members can appeal on the web or in the Mateflow app. See Ban, suspend, or restrict a member.

Find appeals in the appeals queue

Go to Admin → Moderation → Appeals. The sidebar and Appeals in the admin dashboard's Needs attention card show how many are waiting. When members appeal, your team also gets an Appeals waiting notification that opens the pending appeals. In the app, it reads "A member has appealed a moderation decision" and doesn't open anything.

Use Filter by status to show All, Pending, Approved, Rejected, or Closed appeals. Sort shows the newest or oldest first, and you can search by name or username. Each row shows:

  • User: the member who appealed.
  • Restriction: whether it's a Ban, Suspension, or Warning, who imposed it and when, what the member was told, whether it came From a report, and whether their Content deleted with it.
  • Appeal Reason: what the member wrote, and which attempt it is, such as "Appeal 2 of 3".
  • Status, who reviewed it, and when it was Submitted.

Closed means the restriction ended before anyone decided, for example because it was lifted or expired, so the appeal was closed automatically. A pending appeal whose restriction has already ended shows "Restriction no longer in force — nothing to decide".

Approve or reject an appeal

  1. On a Pending appeal, click Approve or Reject.
  2. Read the member's appeal again in the dialog, along with the Internal reason (staff only) recorded with the restriction. If you imposed the restriction yourself, the dialog suggests asking another moderator, but you can still decide.
  3. Optionally add a Note to the member (optional) of up to 500 characters. It's sent to them by email with the decision, so write it for them to read.
  4. Click Approve or Reject to confirm.
  • Approve Appeal: the ban or suspension is lifted, or the warning is withdrawn, and the member is told. They get the notification "Your appeal was approved and the restriction has been lifted", with your note if you added one.
  • Reject Appeal: the restriction stays, and the member is notified that their appeal was rejected. The appeal page then shows Rejected and your note.

If another moderator decided the appeal first, you see "This appeal was already reviewed by another moderator", and the page refreshes to show their decision.

What the member sees on the appeal page

  • The reason: the Reason shown to the member you chose when you restricted them, under Ban Reason, Suspension Reason, or Warning Reason, and your Note to the member under Note from the moderators. A suspension also shows when it ends. Internal notes are never shown.
  • Their appeal and your reply: the appeal's status (Pending Review, Approved, Rejected, or Closed — the restriction has ended), Your Appeal Reason, and your note under Admin Response.
  • Limits: a member can have only one pending appeal per restriction, and can appeal the same restriction up to 3 times. After a rejection, they can appeal again once 24 hours have passed since their last appeal.

See Appeal a moderation decision.

Lift a restriction without an appeal

You don't need an appeal to undo a restriction. Go to Admin → Moderation → Restrictions and click Lift ban or Lift suspension on the Banned or Suspended tab, or Withdraw on the Warnings tab. A pending appeal on it is closed. If the member later opens their appeal page, it says the restriction has already been lifted.

Related articles

Was this guide helpful?

Back to guides

Can't find what you need?

If you're a member of a community, its admins are the right people to ask. If you're building or running one on Mateflow, our team can help.